Government schools vs. parents' rules

 Government schools vs. parents' rules
by Kurt St. Angelo
@2005 Libertarian Writers' Bureau

I usually hold up Indiana’s constitution for the libertarian principles that it embodies, such as individual liberty and self-responsibility. However, in the area of education, Indiana’s constitution is downright communitarian or, shall I say, socialistic.

Article VIII, Section 1 says that the General Assembly shall provide “a general and uniform system of Common Schools, wherein tuition shall be without charge, and equally open to all.” This means that the state has a responsibility to provide education. It also means that every person in Indiana has a constitutional civil right to a public education, for which others must pay. This is the essence of socialism.

There are only two ways our state government can fulfill this education mandate. The first is the way we do it today – in the model of state-run Soviet socialism. Under this regime, the state government controls teachers, curriculum and capital assets, which are education’s so-called means of production.

This is analogous to the Soviet government’s control of energy, natural resources, factories and manpower in its failed production of just about everything. Government schools offer an inferior educational product at nearly twice the price per student compared to private and parochial schools.

There is a reason for poor performance. It’s called lack of competition. No one can control spending and improve quality within a monopolistic system that has no true competitors. If politicians didn’t prop them up by excluding competition, government schools would likely wither away like Soviet state factories.

The other kind of educational system – call it voucher education – would serve us much, much better. Like the original G.I. bill, this policy provides that government pay for education, but not necessarily provide it. This is good for no other reason than government does very little well – which is an especially critical issue when it involves our children.

In a voucher system, parents could chose to what public or approved schools to send their children. For example, students with interests in music or science could select schools with music or science profiles. Other students may pick schools based on special needs. Vouchers mean being able to chose from a variety of schools, given children’s varied needs and interests.

In a voucher system, schools would compete for not only tax dollars, but also for the best teachers. No longer could the state require schools to hire only teachers with the same teaching credentials. Doctors, lawyers and practicing scientists could finally teach without the stamp of approval by some lesser-educated bureaucrat.

With vouchers, each school would be its own self-governing entity, and every student would be given an equal civil right to an equally gratifying education, regardless of his or her background, financial status or neighborhood. Inherent in a voucher system are the principles of efficiency, equality and freedom of choice.

Not surprisingly, Sweden provides universal voucher education for its students. Swedish parents may send their children to any school – government or independent – without paying fees. In only a few years, this policy has inspired an enormous growth in innovative independent schools and encouraged improvements to municipal schools.

Here in America, despite its reputation as the champion of equality, the Democratic Party is one of voucher education’s fiercest opponent. This is because vouchers threaten teacher unions, who put the job security, pay and other special interests of their members ahead of the best interests of our children and communities.

Vouchers offer choice, competition and entrepreneurship in education, which are three things missing in our present Soviet delivery system. Vouchers are likely the only way to not only improve public education, but to save it from its decaying old self.

About the Author

Attorney, screenwriter and Libertarian Party activist in Indianapolis

 Kurt St. Angelo

More Articles 

Thousands of Weapons to be Destroyed by Cambodian Government Next Week in Siem Reap and Sihanoukville. - Marc Vanhemelryck
It is undeniable that Cambodia is changing. When I arrived in Cambodia in 1995, one in three Cambodians I met carried a weapon. Arms were for many the only way to ensure security. Yet, in the decennium I live in Cambodia, I have never seen one used...

Which Government Websites Have Product Recall Information? - Everett Sizemore
There is no one government agency in charge of issuing recall notices for all products. Instead, different products fall under different jurisdictions, each of which is handled by a completely separate agency. In this article we will explain the...

The Benefits Of Government Grants - Paul Graham
Government grants are one of the best ways for you to pay your way through school. But what separates government grants from other types of grants? For starters, governments, unlike individual corporations or banks, usually have a wealth of funds...

An expert opinion about government - Kurt St Angelo
An expert opinion about government by Kurt St. Angelo @2005 Libertarian Writers' Bureau When we have a plumbing problem, we call a plumber. When we have a problem with our government, we call someone who studied government. Right? I majored in...

Government Money for Disaster Victims - Michael Riley
It happened. Now it's time to rebuild. Get up! Do NOT let this break your spirit! Whether it's Hurricane Katrina or a freak accident, the government stands ready right now to help you recover from the disaster that devastated your home and/or your...

Does The Government Really Want You To Quit Smoking? - Peter Howells
The price of whiskey has stayed pretty much the same for the last 10 years in the United Kingdom. The Government exercises its budget every year and as the incumbent Chancellor of the Exchequer Gordon Brown likes to drink whiskey, you could argue...

Government Grants - What are they and how to get them ? - Mike Freemen
None of these Government Grants require a credit check, collateral, security deposits or co-signers, you can apply even if you have a bankruptcy or bad credit, it doesn't matter. Its Free Money Never Repay! The Federal Government is Giving out...

Government Education Loans - Max Bellamy
This article provides useful, detailed information about Government Education Loans. Educational loans are meant for people who cannot afford education. They are a great way to complete higher studies if limited by...

How To Find Free Government Grant Money - Phil Monkton
Finding free government grant money can be time and labor intensive. Identifying the specific agencies and their purposes and specific subject areas can involve a lot of research work. Ads that claim the process is easy usually involve some sort of...

What Is A Government Free Credit Report? - Talbert Williams
Being able to receive your government free credit report is a huge relief for many people. They have been patiently waiting for the day when they could receive their government free credit report; and now they have that chance. A government...

The government does not fulfil its mission completely - Max Weber
I always considered that the government, which consists of elite politicians, is elected to represent national interests and protect people, to prevent wars and maintain national economy. After the Wold War II...

Microsoft Great Plains: Government & Non-Profit Organization – Workflow Implementation - Andrew Karasev
Usually workflow & messaging is realized in CRM and then transactions are just logged into Accounting/ERP/MRP. In the case of Microsoft Business Solutions products: Microsoft Great Plains, Navision, Solomon, Axapta the natural CRM choice would be...